Related
Summary
Patrick Stewart ’s Professor X was one of the defining use of the originalX - Mentrilogy , but the character ’s many appearances are undercut by some unfortunate truths . Alongside Hugh Jackman ’s Wolverine and Robert Downey Jr. ’s Iron Man , Patrick Stewart ’s casting as Charles Xavier is hailed as one of the singlegreatest superhero casting decisions . The esteemed Sir Patrick Stewart lend a horse sense of calm wisdom and gravitas that the X - Men ’s drawing card and moral center deserved , but his character was n’t perfect .
For as great as Stewart ’s performance has been for over twenty years playing the same character , the films he ’s come along in have n’t always treated Charles Xavier as well as his actor has . Often , the inconsistent writing of theconvoluted X - Men timelinehas gotten the better of Professor X , give him some out - of - theatrical role cruelty , naïveté , or foolishness that distinctly only survive to keep the plot make a motion . Other times , the graphic symbol ’s wise man status got the better of him , keeping him out of the public eye until James McAvoy took over in the prequel series .
10Professor X Doesn’t Have Access To His Full Suite Of Powers
The comics' Charles could do far more than read minds
Professor X ’s mutant mutant manifest in the form of powerful telepathy , able-bodied to record and influence the nous of other humans with a mere thought . While Patrick Stewart and James McAvoy alike have been capable to leverage this ability into many amazing covering , theX - Menfilms have lead much of Professor X ’s extended repertory of powers from the strip on the board . It ’s a shameaudiences never experience to see Stewart apply Xavier ’s telekinesis , astral projection , or key signature " mind bolt " .
9The Iconic Hoverchair Wasn’t Done Justice
Professor X’s signature mobility device only got a single underwhelming appearance
Rather than donning aflashy X - Men costume , Professor X became cognize in Marvel Comics for his bright yellowed Hoverchair , a futurist mobility twist befitting of the X - Men ’s venerable drawing card . regrettably , the movies have largely ignored this classic piece of equipment used by Charles , largely throttle Stewart to a terrene wheelchair . While the MCU gave versed fan a taste of the Hoverchair inDoctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness , the pattern of the chair injure up expect like a cockamamie bumper - auto rather than a sleek transportation gimmick .
8Professor X Mostly Exists To Be Tragically Killed Off
Patrick Stewart’s character has died three times already
Patrick Stewart ’s Professor X excels so well as a wise mentor , and surrogate Father-God figure to much of the disco biscuit - Men , that kill him off is a heartrending panorama sure to stimulate a powerful interview reaction . Unfortunately , the films featuring him are all too aware of this . Stewart ’s Charles Xavier has conk out three times now , at the hands of Jean Grey , Wolverine take care - alike X-24 , and Scarlet Witch . At this power point , Xavier ’s last is beginning to lose its emotional impact .
7Professor X’s Treatment Of Jean Grey Was Irredeemable
Charles Xavier’s actions don’t always live up to his kind facade
Charles Xavier is theorise to be a role model for the nascent X - man , many of whom are still grow as adults , let alone brawny ban mutants . Yet Stewart ’s Xavier has done some pretty wicked things over the form of his career , not the least of which being his mistreatment of Jean Grey , who fight with her psychic powers being linked to her unconscious mind . Rather than teach her to control her power , Xavier lock it away behind genial barrierswithout state her , an action that would eventually hail back to bite him with the egress of the Phoenix .
6Professor X Foolishly Wanders Into Stryker’s Trap
Despite his mind-reading, Stewart’s Xavier is easily manipulated
While Patrick Stewart ’s Professor X has some hard reservation regarding needlessly using his powers , it would ’ve behooved him to show more precaution when in the presence of his arch rival and former Quaker , the baddie Magneto . Upon visiting Magneto in prison , Professor X is knock out by a drain gas , not taking enough precaution to read Magneto ’s mind despite his obvious connexion to Stryker and clear ill intent . It ’s an out - of - character moment of clumsiness that wind up leaving him in the detainment of the vile psyche of the Weapon X curriculum .
5Professor X Ignores Doctor Strange’s Warning For No Good Reason
Patrick Stewart’s appearance in the Illuminati is unreasonably foolhardy
Patrick Stewart reprise his part as an substitute - Earth version of Professor X inDoctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness , but did n’t survive the translation without a hefty expiration of sensibility . When Doctor Strange comes before the vague establishment , hoping to fetch the danger that the Scarlet Witch poses , he ’s shrugged off by the Illuminati , including Professor X. This version of the case may technically not be the same Charles , but if his experiences were even remotely similar to the Charles of theX - Menmovies , he would ’ve taken the time to probe Strange ’s psyche to testify his concerns .
4Days Of Future Past Proves Professor X’s Ideals Wrong
In the end, Magneto may have had a point
Charles Xavier has constantly championed the possibility of co - being between mutant and human being throughout the entirety of the X - Men franchise . However , his moral compass seemed to have been undermined by the events of the films themselves , asX - Men : 24-hour interval of Future Pastpresented a drab , dystopian future in which man at last move around against mutantkind , unleashing the annihilating Sentinels . It ’s operose not to agree with Magneto in earlier filmsafter witnessing the ultimate extent to which man was willing to go when it came to eradicate mutants .
3Professor X Is Directly Responsible For The Death Of The X-Men
Though it may have been accidental, Charles Xavier was a walking psychic bomb
The event ofLoganpresented audiences with the most tragic motion-picture show incarnation of Professor X yet . stand from some form of dementia , Charles Xavier wrap up losing ascendence of his powers , leave in a " psychic seizure " that wound hundreds of people and obliterate most of the cristal - valet de chambre in a disaster that became known as the Westchester Incident . Even if this incident was completely unwitting , it implies that Charles failed to take into account the possible inauspicious effects his major power could have on others as his genial wellness decline .
2Professor X Was Too Quick To Forgive Magneto
Time and time again, Professor X let his friendship with the villain cloud his judgement
The most tragic recurring fixture of the X - Men ’s traditional knowledge is Professor X and Magneto ’s former friendship , at last morphing into a reluctant conflict when their react ideals and life experiences get in the way . However poignant this friends - to - enemies discharge was , Patrick Stewart ’s Xavier ofttimes permit his yesteryear to cloud his present - day judgment when it fall to dealing with Magneto . Other than letting his safety down at Magneto ’s prison house inX2 , he bafflingly allows Erik to intrude on his conversations with a volatile Jean Grey inX - Man : The Last Stand .
1Stewart’s Portrayal Isn’t Totally Comics-Accurate
As great as the distinguished actor’s performance is, it isn’t strictly the same character from the comics
Sir Patrick Stewart rightfully made the character of Charles Xavier his own , but not every aspect of Professor X ’s comic origins made the translation to the big screen . For one , Stewart kept his native English accent , which set a case in point for James McAvoy ’s younger Charles to do the same , despite being express as a child growing up in the 40s in New York . More significantly , however , is the actualisation thatProfessor X is a second of a jerkin the comics , with plenty of fishy use of his ability that do n’t befit Stewart ’s ikon ofX - Men ’s honored drawing card .
