Related
Summary
Throughout theStar Warsprequel trilogy , the Jedi Ordermade 10 major mistakes that provedLuke Skywalkerwas right inStar warfare : The Last Jediwhen he accuse the Jedi of a legacy of hubris and nonstarter . InThe Last Jedi , whiletraining Rey on Ahch - To , Luke sound out , " Now that they ’re extinct , the Jedi are romanticized , deified . But if you strip away the myth and look at their human activity , the legacy of the Jedi is failure . Hypocrisy . Hubris . " Although the Jedi Order inthe prequelStar Warstrilogyhave incredible big businessman , they made many decisions that support Luke ’s averment .
When Rey disagree with Luke ’s judgment , he doubles down , arguing,“At the height of their powers , they allowed Darth Sidious to rise , create the Empire , and wipe them out . It was a Jedi Master who was responsible for the training and creation of Darth Vader . “While aspects of these claim are complicated , they all , to some degree , hold true . Darth Sidious was also Chancellor Palpatine , and he took over the Senate and established the Empire under the Jedi Order ’s nose , and , of row , Anakin Skywalker , a Jedi , became Darth Vader . These errors stem in part from the Jedi ’s moral shifts and clouded perspective in the Clone Wars , and here are 10 of their bounteous mistakes .
What ’s the best way to watch Star Wars ? Here ’s everything you ask to know to watch in loss or timeline parliamentary law , and how to include the TV show .
10The Jedi Didn’t Address Anakin’s Anger, Sadness, & Fear
Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace
Anakin openly display issues with anger , foiling , and venerate throughout theStar Warsprequel trilogy , which urinate it surprising that the Jedi Order did not ill-treat in in the first place or much at all . When he arrives on Coruscant , Anakin give tongue to lugubriousness about and a hungriness for his mother . Of course , he was novel to the Jedi and was raised with typical transmitted bonds , so it made sensory faculty , but it ’s unreadable how the Jedi actively work with Anakin to move past those feelings ; apparently , they did n’t . AfterThe Phantom Menace , Anakin ’s behaviour only became more pronounced , with him systematically lashing out even in front of the Council .
When Anakin yells that the Council ’s decision to not grant him the membership of Jedi Master is ' outrageous ' and ' unfair , ' the Council does little more than tell him to take a prat . When Anakin brings intense paranoia about suffer a get it on one to Master Yoda , Yoda tells him to let go of his care but does not address that this demonstrate a severe attachment . It ’s unclear why the Council did n’t take more action . InThe Clone Warsseries , Yoda assigns Anakin a Padawan , Ahsoka Tano , perhaps to better these behaviors , but she becomes another attachment . It ’s possible the Council simply gave too much weighting tothe Chosen Oneprophecy .
9The Jedi Didn’t Sense The Dark Side In Palpatine
Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith
A common critical review of the Jedi Order is their oversight in regularly act upon alongside a Sith Lord , andwhile Palpatine was brawny enough to conceal his use of the dark side from the Jedi , it was n’t only efficient . InRevenge of the Sith , Mace Windu says,“The dark side of the Force surrounds the Chancellor,“signaling that it was more or less perceivable . It ’s rum that the Jedi did n’t take that one whole tone further and identify Palpatine as the Sith Lord Count Dooku warn Obi - Wan about . base on their incredulity at the estimate , though , it ’s possible they believed the Sith were sincerely go thanks to the Jedi — loaning to the ' hubris ' argument .
8The Jedi Accepted The Clones Without Fully Understanding Their Origin
Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones
One of the most confounding patch points in all ofStar Warsis the fact that the Jedi take the dead ringer troopers , having antecedently had no awareness of their creation . The circumstances around the clones seem suspicious at best , and throughout his trip to Kamino , Obi - Wan bring in it cleared that he desire neither the Kaminoans nor Jango Fett . Despite the mystery remaining largely unsolved — while it comes to light that Master Sifo - Dyas had a mitt in it , the serendipity of the clone trooper creation aline with The Clone Wars is a number too convenient — the Jedi accept the USA as their own .
This bear witness to be a fatal determination , as the clones come with inhibitor microchip that , with their proximity to the Jedi and the trust they build up with them , enable Palpatine to carry outOrder 66 , wiping out the Jedi . It ’s likely that , as Palpatine want , the Jedi were painted into a corner with the issue of the Clone Wars , and the clones offer a itinerary fore . Part of the event was that the Jedi overstepped their part in that determination ; they were n’t meant to be soldier forge for the Republic , and by undercut what should have been their role in the wandflower , they brought their own closing .
7The Jedi Became Soldiers, Not Peacekeepers
Along with their acceptance of the clone trooper came the Jedi ’s acceptance that they would be mesh in the Clone Wars as soldiers , basically working for the Republic . This was contrary to the Jedi way and their bequest as peacekeepers in the extragalactic nebula , and that showed in how lost many of the Jedi , in particular Padawans , became during the state of war . Ahsoka Tano , Anakin Skywalker ’s former Padawan , specifically reflected on this in the Clone Wars geological era flashback in theAhsokaseries . Her year as a youngling in the orderliness , before the warfare , had simply not prepared her for the life of a soldier because that was n’t what Jedi were meant to be .
6The Jedi Didn’t Heed Barriss Offee’s Warnings
Star Wars: The Clone Wars
ordinate with this issue of Jedi becoming soldier , betray what they were meant to be , was the emergence of Barriss Offee as a Jedi Padawan who fell to the dark side inThe Clone Warsseries . Interestingly , Barriss ' rationale for turn to the sorry side was not dissimilar from the anxieties Ahsoka voiced in theAhsokaseries flashback prospect . When Barriss is set up shamefaced of the execution Ahsoka had been accused of , she shares that many have mislay religious belief in the Jedi because of their engagement in the state of war . In front of the Senate , she explain :
I did it . Because I ’ve come to realize what many people in the Republic have come to see . That the Jedi are the ones responsible for for this War . That we ’ve so lost our way that we have become the villains in this conflict . That we are the ones that should be put on trial , all of us ! And my attack on the Temple was an attack on what the Jedi have become . An U. S. Army fighting for the Dark Side , devolve from the Light that we once held so dear . This Republic is failing ! It ’s only a matter of meter .
Had the Jedi listened to this perspective , they may have been capable to undo some of the equipment casualty done throughout the Clone Wars , if not change their fate . While Palpatine ’s programme had already been very much set in motion , these opinions by Barriss are ultimately echoed by Anakin on Mustafar when he is justifying his own turn to the dark side , telling Obi - Wan,“From my point - of - aspect , the Jedi are evil . “Anakin was present when Barriss made this showcase , and this , combined with the Jedi turn away from Ahsoka , sure as shooting contributed to his shift in linear perspective . Unfortunately , perhaps solely because Barriss was a dark side substance abuser , the Jedi cut her pleas .
5The Jedi Held Too Tightly To Their Rule Against Attachments
Anakin is perhaps the most pronounced example of the issues with the Jedi ’s ruler against attachments because his need to hold back his marriage to Padmé , compounded with his paranoia about losing her , sends him directly toward the dark side , but he is sure not the only example . In fact , shockingly , inThe Clone Warsseries , Satine Kyrze , Duchess of Mandalore , declare her love for Obi - Wan , and he reveals that he would have leave the Order for her . The Jedi Order put themselves at odds with the Jedi who had these connections despite the fact thatit was likely time for a modernized update to the rule .
It ’s interesting to compare this rule against attachments from the prequel epoch ’s Jedi Order to the eccentric of attachments Luke Skywalker go bad on to have after the events of the original trilogy , both in canyon and in Legends . In the original trilogy , it could be argued that Luke has an adherence , at minimum , to his twin sis Leia . While it ’s certainly not the type of possessive family relationship Anakin had with the mass he have it off , it ’s a transmitted connection that was concerning to the prequels ' Jedi Order . In Legends , Luke Skywalker even had a wife , Mara Jade , showing thatJedi can have attachments without fall to the sullen side .
At the meter of Order 66 and the Great Jedi Purge , there were several major member of the High Jedi Council . This is what you demand to lie with about them .
4The Jedi Abandoned Ahsoka
The Jedi Council ’s determination to remove Ahsoka from the Jedi Order when she was falsely accused of murder conduce significantly to Anakin ’s want of faith in them and march the parliamentary law ’s flaws . Although Ahsoka had proven herself time and again to the Order , push valorously in the Clone Wars and embody Jedi compassion for those she encountered throughout the galaxy , when she was accused of slaying , they cast her by . This ultimately go toAhsoka leaving the Jedi Orderand created doubt in Anakin ’s head ; he , like the Council , knew Ahsoka well , but in direct contrast , he never doubted her and work tirelessly to encounter the true liquidator and well-defined Ahsoka ’s name .
In plus to the effects on Ahsoka and Anakin , though , the Jedi expose one of their biggest fault with their decision . By removing Ahsoka from the Order , the Jedi had made it so that the Senate had legal power to engage her ; she had antecedently been protect by her status as a Jedi Padawan . This seemed to have been done in large part because there was atmospheric pressure from the Senate to reach Ahsoka over . While they may have thought her guilty , it ’s more likely thatthis was a thoughtfulness of how much the Jedi had begun to prioritize the Republic over their own Order and their ideals .
3The Jedi Became Too Political
The Jedi regularly met with Chancellor Palpatine and permit him enough engagement in the Jedi Order that he was capable to insist that Anakin be put on the Jedi Council . Palpatine , as the Chancellor of the Republic Senate , should never have had that level of influence on the Jedi , but because of the Jedi ’s role in the Clone Wars and their associations with the Senate , those line were blurred . The Jedi were effectively working for the Senate , involving themselves in what should have been solely a political war . In so doing , they transformed what the Jedi and the Order were for , entering political relation rather than focusing on continue the peace .
2The Jedi Didn’t Act Even As Palpatine Grew More Powerful
Even without knowing that Palpatine was a Sith Lord , the Jedi should have been aware that , as Chancellor , he was gaining more and more power and was therefore becoming a scourge . Although Palpatine frequently gave mouth table service to the fact that all his power was temporary and he would merrily relinquish that power once the warfare ended , his raise should have been more alarming to the Jedi . InRevenge of the Sith , Obi - Wan expresses to Anakin that Palpatine has too much king and has contend to hold onto it , but it was too later ; the Jedi had stood by and , as Luke said , allow Palpatine to rise to power .
1The Jedi Never Sensed The Dark Side In Anakin
Palpatine may have had the skills to conceal his status as a Sith from the Jedi and dim them to his use of the non-white side , but Anakin did not . In fact , Yoda even sense pain and last tie in to Anakin after he slaughter the Tuskens . Yoda seemingly never oppugn Anakin about what he sense , though , as a further demonstration of the Jedi ’s rule of count the other room . While the Holy Order also represented how important the Jedi can be , Luke ’s criticisms carry true . Rey ’s new Jedi Orderwill face that history in the upcomingStar Warsfilm , hopefully come up to these pitfalls to obviate history reduplicate itself .
AllStar Warsmovies & television receiver shows are streaming on Disney+ .
