Related
Summary
There have been 12 Starfleet Commodores in the story ofStar Trek , however , not every character to hold the membership has had the best of intention . Placed between Captain and Admiral , Starfleet ’s Commodore rankis the lowest ranking flag officeholder , who can be in control of a fleet of ships . InStar Trek : Picardseason 3 , Commodore Geordi La Forge ( LeVar Burton ) was the most recent officer to attain the rank for his study in overseeing the Athan Prime Fleet Museum ’s aggregation of classical starship .
unhappily , noteveryStar TrekCommodoreis as trustworthy and honorable as Geordi LaForge . Although the Commodore rank does n’t draw in nearly as many corrupted officer as that of Admiral , there have still been some villainous or misguidedStar TrekCommodores . The worst offence of Starfleet Commodores inStar Trekrange from almost getting the USS Enterprise destroy to overseeing a massive conspiracy that claimed the life-time of over 92,000 masses .
For a progressive , utopian institution , Starfleet has more than a few bad apple that have their own unique approach to maintaining galactic peace .
12Commodore Oh (Tamlyn Tomita)
Star Trek: Picard Season 1
Star Trek : Picard ’s Commodore Oh ( Tamlyn Tomita ) was incredibly good at her job , so she ’s technically better than some of her predecessors . However , Oh ’s intentions were so villainous and genocidal that she is surely the worst Starfleet Commodore of all fourth dimension . As a recondite - coverRomulan Tal Shiaragent , Oh orchestrated the withering First Contact daylight attacks on the Utopia Planitia Shipyards , which do the deaths of over 90,000 hoi polloi . To extend her plan to illegalize synthetical spirit , she grade the end of Dahj Asha ( Isa Briones ) and manipulated Dr. Agnes Jurati ( Alison Pill ) into remove Dr. Bruce Maddox .
11Commodore Stocker (Charles Drake)
Star Trek: TOS, season 2, episode 11, “The Deadly Years”
Star Trek : The Original Series ' Commodore Stocker ( Charles Drake ) was n’t a villain , he was a mankind who was deplorably out of his profoundness . In " The Deadly Years " , Captain James T. Kirk ( William Shatner ) and the crew of the USS Enterprise succumbed to a mysterious aging disease . A frightened and inexperienced Stocker strike command of the ship and took the Enterprise hazardously close to the Romulan Neutral Zonein his attempt to reach Starbase 10 more quickly . gratefully , Kirk was cured , retook command of the Enterprise , and avoided set off another warfare with the Romulans . Kirk hold the inexperienced Stocker no inauspicious will .
10Commodore Matt Decker (William Windom)
Star Trek: TOS, season 2, episode 6, “The Doomsday Machine”
Commodore Matt Decker ( William Windom ) was a serviceman driven to desperate action by grief and guilt trip . Decker was obsessed with destruct the titulary major planet killer inStar Trek : The Original Series ' " The Doomsday auto " . While Decker wanted to destroy the satellite killer to protect the galaxy , he was more labour by avenging the gang that he lost while in control of the USS Constellation . In doing so , Decker risks the lifetime of Captain Kirk and the work party of the USS Enterprise , abandoning the commanding officer ’s duty to protect their crew . After Decker sacrificed himself , Kirk preserved the Commodore ’s report in his report .
9Commodore Tafune (Russell Yeun)
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, season 2, episode 1, “The Broken Circle”
In his abbreviated appearance inStar Trek : unusual New Worldsseason 2 , instalment 1 , " The Broken Circle " , Commodore Tafune ( Russell Yeun ) questioned the judgment of his superior officer , Admiral Robert April ( Adrian Holmes ) . During a meeting with Admiral April about the threat posed by theGorn Hegemony , Tafune suggest that his superior had locomote " too easy " on Lt . Spock ( Ethan Peck ) for stealing the USS Enterprise . Given that Spock averted another Federation - Klingon War , Commodore Tafune should have given the Vulcan mutineer far more credit .
8Commodore Chiv (Eugene Clark)
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, season 2, episode 2, “Ad Astra per Aspera”
Commodore Chiv ( Eugene Clark ) was a fellow member of the judgement panel inStar Trek : Strange New Worlds ' visitation of Commander Una Chin - Riley(Rebecca Romijn ) . As a Vulcan , Chiv ’s thought process on Number One ’s Illyrian heritage and her failure to disclose her genetical sweetening were hard to discern . pass on the final conclusion to accord Una asylum and countenance her to continue serve aboard the USS Enterprise , it ’s safe to take up that the inscrutable Commodore Chiv fit in with the eleemosynary discernment of Number One .
7Commodore Barstow (Richard Derr)
Star Trek: TOS, season 1, episode 20, “The Alternative Factor”
Commodore Barstow ( Richard Derr ) apprise Kirk ’s Enterprise to bear on its probe into a Galax urceolata - wide of the mark upshot inStar Trek : The Original Series , season 1 , installment 20 , " The Alternative Factor " . Unlike Commodores Decker and Oh , Barstow was play for the neat good , believing that the magnetic disruption posed a serious terror to galactic safety . Barstow know that the Enterprise crew was the intimately - equipped team in the Starfleet armada to fix the problem , which was why he ordered Kirk to proceed his investigating while simultaneously ordering other spaceship to empty the area around the mysterious satellite .
6Commodore Stone (Percy Rodriguez)
Star Trek: TOS, season 1, episode 14, “Court Martial”
In " Court Martial " , Commodore Stone ( Percy Rodriguez ) investigated charge of acrime committed by Captain Kirk- the murder of a fellow officer . Stone never persecuted Kirk and instead follow the evidence as it was presented to him . Crucially , Stone decided to go down with the endeavour during the courtroom - martialwhen Kirk ’s fight with the psychotic Lt . Commander Benjamin Finney ( Richard Webb ) endangered the ship . While he may have been puttingStar Trek : The Original Series ' hero on test for a offense he did n’t commit , Commodore Stone did so with unity and fairness .
5Commodore Paris (Shohreh Aghdashloo)
Star Trek Beyond (2016)
Commodore Paris ( Shohreh Aghdashloo ) was the overlook officer of the rotatory starbase , the USS Yorktown inStar Trek Beyond . Paris provided Captain James T. Kirk ( Chris Pine ) with valuable , if subtle , advice on whether he should accept a forwarding to Vice - Admiral . After he saved the Yorktown from Krall ( Idris Elba ) , Admiral Paris enjoin Kirk that the advancement was his , but also prompt him that Admirals do n’t fly . Paris ' insidious nudge helped the Kelvin Timeline Kirk debar one of the biggest error of his Prime Timeline counterpart .
4Commodore Bob Wesley (Barry Russo)
Star Trek: TOS, season 2, episode 24, “The Ultimate Computer”
Commodore Bob Wesley ( Barry Russo ) lost his crew when the M-5 data processor created by Dr. Richard Daystrom ( William Marshall ) croak rapscallion and twist the USS Enterprise into a weapon of aggregate destruction . Wesley ’s entire gang was killed when the M-5 turn on his ship , the USS Lexington . While Wesley receive license from Starfleet Command to destroy the Enterprise and Dr. Richard Daystrom ’s malfunction computer , he keep back his fire because he believed that Kirk would deliver the goods in deactivating the M-5 . Captain Kirk did eventually talk the M-5 into deactivate itself , signify that Commodore Wesley never had to draw out the trigger .
A retired Commodore Wesley appear in theStar Trek : The Animated Seriesepisode " One of our planet is Missing " , voiced by Scotty actor James Doohan .
Richard Daystrom played a major part in the mental synthesis of the USS Enterprise , and continues to influence the Star Trek world 200 geezerhood by and by .
3Commodore José I. Mendez (Malachi Throne)
Star Trek: The Original Series, Episodes 15 & 16, “The Menagerie”
Commodore José I. Mendez ( Malachi Throne ) oversaw Starbase 11 , and the overall fear of Fleet Captain Christopher Pike ( Sean Kenney ) follow his tragical accident . In the classicStar Trek : The Original Seriestwo - parter , " The Menagerie " , Mendez and Kirk go after down Spock after he ’d stolen the Enterprise and lead for Talos IV . While the Mendez that joined Kirk and conducted Spock ’s courtroom - martial was illusory , the real Mendez still shortly lifted General Order 4 to permit Pike to live out his retirement in an illusory Eden . Mendez was dedicate to Pike ’s upbeat right up to the end .
