Related
Summary
One of George Lucas ' biggest decisions with theStar Warsprequel trilogy has square reasoning behind it . Upon the prequels ' sack in 1999 , the movies were largely controversial . Many held the belief that the prequels were rate among theworstStar Warsmovies of all clock time , with only the release of the equally factious sequel serial trigger an era of revisionism for Lucas ' 2nd trilogy .
The Star Wars enfranchisement ’s Skywalker Saga is comprised of three famous picture trilogies , but one stands head and shoulders above the sleep .
Among the criticism shoot for at theatrical role like Jar Jar Binks , Lucas ' overreliance on CGI , and the excessively monotone writing of the moving picture ' playscript , perhaps the most controversial vista of theStar Warsprequel trilogy was the type of Anakin Skywalker . When watching theStar Warsmovies in chronological order , the prequels do as a way to explicate how Anakin Skywalker became Darth Vader . Lucas ' manipulation of Anakin ’s character and this history arc take in their just share of criticism , though one element of the theatrical role - specificallyAnakin Skywalker ’s age inStar Wars- has been explained by Lucas with profound logic .
Anakin Was Almost A Teenager In The Phantom Menace
One of the moderately controversial decisions Lucas made with Anakin inStar Wars : Episode I - The Phantom Menacewas the character ’s young age . However , Pablo Hidalgo - a longtime adviser of Lucasfilm concerningStar Warsproperties - has outlined that Lucas almost made Anakin a teenager in the first prequel film . The character bookStar Wars : Fascinating Factsconfirms thatLucas continuously run back and onward on Anakin ’s age , torn between produce the character a nine - year - old small fry or a somewhat older stripling .
Eventually , Lucas committed to portraying Anakin as a baby inThe Phantom Menace . The rationality for this stemmed from the mind that Anakin ’s human relationship with his mother was intact to the character . If Anakin was older in the first prequel , the concept of leave alone his mother behind may not have been as difficult a decision . However , depicting Anakin as a young child who is still reliant on his female parent make the former leave behind the latter more heartbreakinggiven the stronger connection between the two .
George Lucas Made The Right Decision To Keep Anakin Younger
As it reverse out , Lucas definitely made the correct decision to have Anakin be portrayed at a young eld inThe Phantom Menace . The main rationality for this comes from the centrality Shmi Skywalker has to Anakin ’s fall to the dark side . The first hints at Anakin ’s grim tendencies come inStar Wars : Episode II - Attack of the Cloneswhere he massacres a tribe of Tusken Raiders who nobble his female parent .
Anakin charge himself for this outcome due to his determination to allow for his mother behind on Tatooine as a shaver . This relationship begins Anakin ’s transition into Darth Vader which is eventually sold more due to the strong connection he had with his mother as a baby . If this connective was not as predominant - if Anakin had been an angsty stripling in the first movie , for model - the character ’s fall to the dark side may not have workedas well . Therefore , one of Lucas ' unnumerable controversial decisions for theStar Warsprequels was made with sound reasoning in mind .
