Yellowstone
Summary
An emergingYellowstonefan theory suggests that a strike down time of year - one secret plan point could resolve Kevin Costner ’s untimely exit from the show ahead ofYellowstoneseason 5 , part 2 — the long - awaited series finale . In the first part of the fifth time of year , Costner ’s John Dutton III , the season Dutton patriarch and owner of Yellowstone Ranch , became the fresh minted governor of Montana . Despite his new side , John ’s still manage with historic period - old job : the destiny of the ranch land is at stake — as is the Dutton legacy . Unfortunately , the neo - Western is n’t primed to adequately conclude John ’s arc .
Reportedly , Costner and serial co - Divine Taylor Sheridan sparred over creative deviation . Unhappy with the show ’s direction , Costner refused to ratify off on an termination for John Dutton until he register one he truly conceive in . This behind - the - scene friction go Costner to quitYellowstonealtogether , which means John Dutton wo n’t be appearing in time of year 5 , part 2.It ’s hard to fancy asatisfying manner for Kevin Costner to leaveYellowstone — and the character of John Dutton III . Even so , one theory posits an interesting bend that ’s rooted in a long - forgotten season - one patch item .
John Dutton Had Colon Cancer In Yellowstone Season 1
The Dutton patriarch was introduce to viewers as a man who ’d do anything to protect his family ’s cattle farm , and , with that , their hard - won bequest . The demesne that the Dutton ranch engage borders the Broken Rock Reservation and Yellowstone National Park , motivate various mathematical group to fight for control of the dimension . When witness suffer the Duttons , it ’s unmortgaged that the battle has been going on for generations . Not to advert , John does n’t have an obvious successor , leave the fate of the cattle ranch in even mirky soil . This is further complicated byJohn Dutton having Crab inYellowstoneseason 1 .
Although John ’s experience with colon genus Cancer is divulge to viewers , he hides the wellness scare from his adult children — Beth ( Kelly Reilly ) , Jamie ( Wes Bentley ) , and Kayce ( Luke Grimes ) . BetweenJamie and Beth ’s ongoingYellowstonerivalryto John ’s pregnant kinship with Kayce , the inter - family dramatic play encourages John to remain tight - lipped . Eventually , Beth and Jamie discover their father ’s secret . While John tell them that he ’s in near wellness , things take a drastic turn at the terminal of time of year 1 , win over John ( and viewers ) that the Aspinwall genus Cancer has resurface .
Another Season Already Teased The Return Of John Dutton’s Illness
Undoubtedly , John ’s illness was introduced inYellowstone ’s first season in orderliness to apply more insistency to the ranch ’s successor patch . In theYellowstoneseason 2 premiere , the show leans into this spectacular account melodic line ( and , ostensibly , resolve it ) . After John crumble on the spread , everyone around him , include the ranch ’s vet , fear the worst . However , when Costner ’s fibre coughs up lineage , the vet realizes he ’s really suffering from a ruptured ulcer . The emergency surgical process end with the vet cauterizing John ’s wound . With the comeback of John ’s cancer being a fake - out , Yellowstonegoes on to abandon the thread whole .
Even though time of year 2 ofYellowstonealready tease the return of John Dutton ’s aliveness - threatening illness , enough clock time has pass inYellowstone ’s timelinefor the character ’s colon cancer plot of ground communication channel to render in season 5 . In other instances , the convenient recurrence of a potentially concluding illness could degrade the chronicle . However , with Costner ’s deviation hanging over time of year 5 , part 2 , happen a canonical reason for the character ’s exit might sit down better with viewers . It ’s surd to knowwhat to expect fromYellowstoneseason 5 , part 2 , but the return of John Dutton ’s Cancer the Crab is looking a piddling more likely .
The Return Of John Dutton’s Cancer Means The Show Could Write Off Kevin Costner In Yellowstone Season 5, Part 2
WhileYellowstoneseason 5 ending without Costner feel wrong , it does n’t seem likely that the player will return at all when the show set out production . In time of year 5 , part 1 , John does n’t have genus Cancer or any obvious health scares . Instead , he ’s weathering a potential impeachment and the on-going fight for the ranch land . Of of course , the first one-half of season 5 was conceive before Costner ’s divergence was do in Harlan Stone . While an off - cover death might sense stilted , Yellowstonehas certainly laid the basis for John Dutton ’s cancer plot , making it a probable go - to in the serial publication close .
